Why Am I So Single Musical – Full Guide to Cast, Tickets and Reviews

A new musical from the creators of Six has arrived in London’s West End, turning the chaos of modern dating into a theatrical event. Why Am I So Single? opened at the Garrick Theatre in late 2024 and quickly became one of the most talked-about new productions of the season.

The show follows two best friends, Oliver and Nancy, as they swipe, ghost, and stumble through the world of dating apps. It is a two-hander comedy that examines singledom in an era dominated by Tinder, Bumble, Grindr, and Hinge. Written by Toby Marlow and Lucy Moss, the duo behind the global phenomenon Six, this production marks their highly anticipated follow-up.

With a West End run that spanned from August 2024 to January 2025, the musical established itself as a significant new entry in British theatre. Audiences and critics alike responded to its blend of sharp wit, heartfelt observation, and large-scale musical spectacle.

What Is the Musical ‘Why Am I So Single’ About?

• This is the highly anticipated follow-up to Six, one of the biggest modern musicals of the past decade.
• The musical is loosely autobiographical, written by Marlow and Moss about their own dating lives.
• The show premiered in the West End in 2024 and drew large audiences throughout its run.
• Unlike Six, which is a historical pop concert, this is a contemporary two-hander comedy.
• The plot centres on two chronically single best friends navigating apps, awkward dates, and their own expectations.
• It has been described as a “love letter” to dating in the digital age.

The story follows Oliver and Nancy, two best friends who are both single and questioning why. As they move through the landscape of modern romance, the musical explores friendship, self-doubt, and the pressure to couple up. Reviews and official descriptions have framed it as a “big fancy musical” and a “musical extravaganza” that tackles dating in the age of Tinder, Bumble, Grindr, and Hinge.

Marlow and Moss have described the show as loosely based on their own experiences, giving the comedy an autobiographical undercurrent. The musical is explicitly a two-hander, meaning the narrative weight falls primarily on the two lead performers, a structural choice that distinguishes it from the ensemble format of Six.

For those unfamiliar with the creators’ earlier work, SIX the Musical: Everything You Need to Know provides a detailed overview of the show that made them famous.

Who Is in the Cast of ‘Why Am I So Single’?

The principal cast of the West End production featured three named performers in leading roles. Jo Foster and Leesa Tulley played the “eternally single” best friends at the centre of the story. Noah Thomas was also listed among the principal cast. Additional alternate leads and ensemble performers were publicly documented but were subject to change during the run.

Who wrote the musical?

The musical was written by Toby Marlow and Lucy Moss, the same creative duo behind Six. Their official website and multiple listings explicitly frame Why Am I So Single? as the follow-up to that global hit. Marlow and Moss both wrote the book, music, and lyrics for this production.

Who are the main characters?

The two central characters are Oliver and Nancy, described as best friends who are both navigating the challenges of being single in a world dominated by dating apps. The narrative follows their individual romantic misadventures and the friendship that anchors them.

The Salterton Arts Review noted that the show’s dynamic rests on the chemistry between the two leads, with the plot moving between their separate dating lives and their shared conversations about what it all means.

Where Can I Buy Tickets For ‘Why Am I So Single’?

The documented West End run of Why Am I So Single? took place at the Garrick Theatre in London from 27 August 2024 to 19 January 2025. That specific season has now concluded. Multiple ticket sellers including London Theatre, TodayTix, and West End Theatre listed performances for that run.

For those asking about current availability, the situation remains unclear. The supplied research does not confirm a 2025–2026 extension of the London run or a nationwide UK tour. Some sources, including the Garrick Theatre ticket page, may provide updates on future performances if they are scheduled.

The London Theatre show page and TodayTix listing previously carried ticketing information for the Garrick run. Whether new dates or a touring production will be announced remains to be seen.

For a broader view of current London theatre offerings, readers may consult Best West End Shows in London 2025.

Is There a Soundtrack for ‘Why Am I So Single’?

As of the available information, a full cast recording or original soundtrack album has not been officially announced. The research does not confirm the release of a complete studio album for this musical. This remains one of the gaps in publicly accessible information about the show.

What does exist is the title track, which was released and promoted ahead of the West End run. BroadwayWorld reported on the title track’s release in September 2024, offering audiences a preview of the musical’s sound and style.

Additionally, the cast performed the song “8 Dates” at the Olivier Awards 2025, as documented on YouTube. This performance indicates that at least some of the show’s music has been presented beyond the theatre run, though it does not confirm a full soundtrack release.

What are the lyrics to the songs?

Lyrics for Why Am I So Single? have not been officially published online by the creators or the production. While some audience members have transcribed portions of songs from performances, no authorised lyric sheet or libretto is publicly available. The content plan identifies this as a known gap in the show’s online presence.

What Did Critics Say About ‘Why Am I So Single’?

Critical reception for the musical was broadly positive, with several major outlets offering strong endorsements. The Garrick Theatre’s own promotional materials quoted The Times calling the show “riotously life-affirming” and the Financial Times describing it as a “dazzling new musical from the creators of SIX.”

The Salterton Arts Review awarded the production 4 out of 5 stars, calling it a “feelgood musical” that successfully translates the energy of its creators’ previous work into a new context. The review highlighted the chemistry between the leads and the show’s comedic timing.

Multiple reviewers noted the show’s status as a follow-up to Six, and opinions varied on whether it matched that production’s impact. The comparison was unavoidable given the creators’ previous success, but most critics acknowledged the show as a distinct work with its own identity.

Audience reaction during the Garrick Theatre run appeared positive, with sold-out performances and strong word of mouth. Formal audience rating data from aggregator sites was not consistently available across all sources.

When Did ‘Why Am I So Single’ Premiere and What Is Its Performance History?

The musical’s journey from concept to stage unfolded over several years. Below is a timeline based on available information.

1. 2020–2022: Development and workshops of the musical took place, with Marlow and Moss writing the book, music, and lyrics.
2. 2023: The project was first publicly announced by Marlow and Moss as their follow-up to Six.
3. 27 August 2024: Preview performances began at the Garrick Theatre in London.
4. September 2024: The title track was released, giving audiences a first listen to the show’s music.
5. 2025: The cast performed “8 Dates” at the Olivier Awards, and the West End run concluded on 19 January 2025.
6. 2025–2026: No confirmed UK tour or extension has been publicly documented in the available research.

The Wikipedia article for the musical provides additional context on the production’s development history and creative background.

What Is Confirmed and What Remains Uncertain About the Musical?

For readers trying to get a clear picture of this production, it helps to separate what is established from what remains unclear.

What Makes ‘Why Am I So Single’ Different from SIX and Other Musicals?

As the sophomore effort from the creators of Six, Why Am I So Single? inevitably invites comparison. The most significant difference is structural: where Six is an ensemble pop concert built around six historical queens, this show is a two-hander focused on two contemporary characters.

The thematic shift is equally notable. Six reimagined Tudor history through a modern pop lens; Why Am I So Single? turns its attention entirely to the present day, examining dating culture in a post-pandemic world. The show engages directly with dating apps, the pressure to couple up, and the experience of being single in your twenties and thirties.

Marlow and Moss have described the musical as loosely based on their own lives, adding a layer of personal authenticity that distinguishes it from their earlier work. The shift from historical queens to modern dating also allows for a different kind of comedy—more observational, more conversational, and grounded in shared contemporary experience.

What Do Reviews and Critics Say About the Show?

Several notable critical voices weighed in on the production during its West End run.

“Riotously life-affirming… an all-singing, all-dancing musical extravaganza.”

— The Times, as quoted by the Garrick Theatre

“A dazzling new musical from the creators of SIX.”

— Financial Times, as quoted by the Garrick Theatre

“A feelgood musical… 4/5.”

— Salterton Arts Review

The Musical Theatre Musings review offered additional perspective on the production’s strengths and weaknesses, noting the show’s ambition and the performers’ energy.

Should You Watch ‘Why Am I So Single’?

For fans of Toby Marlow and Lucy Moss, this musical offers a chance to see what the duo created after the phenomenon of Six. Its exploration of modern dating, performed by a strong cast and built around a two-hander structure, earned positive reviews and a devoted audience during its West End run. Whether future performances or a tour will materialise remains unconfirmed, but the show has already established itself as a notable entry in contemporary British musical theatre.

Frequently Asked Questions